Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 2
Thought for Today, September 8, 2025
Dale Partridge: “The Israel Delusion”: Book Review, Part 2
Logical fallacies. Unfortunately, Partridge’s book contains several of them.
The most common is making false comparisons and parallels along the line of: since “A” is to “B”, then in the same way, “C” (often closely related to “A”) must be to “D”. His comparisons often seem to be designed to appeal to one’s emotions.
An example of that type of fallacy would be: a person who has allergies to peanuts should not eat them, as they could die from an allergic reaction (“A” is to “B”). Since some have allergies to peanuts, no one should be served peanuts (“C” is to “D”). Another, more controversial example that is used almost daily: a person used a gun to murder someone. Since someone used a gun to murder someone, no one should be able to own a gun.
As for Partridge’s book, perhaps the most egregious example is his mentioning a guest appearance by a Rabbi at a church. During the discussion, the question comes up: Did the Jews kill Jesus? The minister, seeking to be polite says that we all did, Jews and Gentiles alike. Partridge does not quote the Rabbi directly, but states that in essence he said in so many words…. Partridge then references a Wikipedia article that states that the Talmud, Gitten 57a, says that Jesus was demon possessed, is facing God’s wrath, and is boiling in excrement. Thus the Rabbi’s statement, thus the Talmud, and by inference, thus all Jews.
Let us take a detailed look at Gitten 57a. What does it say? The passage deals with a necromancer, Onkelos, who calls up both Balaam and Jesus, asking each of them what their punishment in the afterlife is. It is true that Gitten 57a does speak of Jesus suffering the punishment of being in boiling excrement (the meaning of then named character, “Yashu,” is sometimes debated, and not all texts include it). What is curious is that the text goes on to state that Yashu sought the good of the people whereas Balaam desired their harm. The key point for our purposes is that the text declares that both spirits were brought up through the use of necromancy by Onkelos.
Consider Deuteronomy 18:10–11 (ESV): “There shall not be found among you anyone who burns his son or his daughter as an offering, anyone who practices divination or tells fortunes or interprets omens, or a sorcerer or a charmer or a medium or a necromancer or one who inquires of the dead, for whoever does these things is an abomination to the LORD. And because of these abominations the LORD your God is driving them out before you.”
Doesn’t the Torah itself invalidate what the Talmud speaks of in this case? Given how the passage forbids the use of necromancy as found in Gitten 57a, what does that say about Onkelos? it is not wise to ground one’s conclusions based on that Talmudic passage. Does using demonic methods to get an answer ever result in anything good? No. Are demons known for being truthful? No. Jesus stated that Satan was the father of lies.
Nevertheless, Partridge uses this argument for his theological position against the Jews and against Israel. It is noteworthy that antisemites tend to favor the Talmud over the Torah, the non-canonical and sometimes, as here, its anti-biblical writings over the Hebrew canon. The Talmud includes all sorts of things that the Torah does not. As we have just noted, the Old Testament makes it clear that those who engage in occultic practices such as necromancy are eternally lost.
And that leads us to Partridge’s replacement theology, which we will examine in the next post.
Dale Partridge: “The Israel Delusion”: Book Review, Part 2
Logical fallacies. Unfortunately, Partridge’s book contains several of them.
The most common is making false comparisons and parallels along the line of: since “A” is to “B”, then in the same way, “C” (often closely related to “A”) must be to “D”. His comparisons often seem to be designed to appeal to one’s emotions.
An example of that type of fallacy would be: a person who has allergies to peanuts should not eat them, as they could die from an allergic reaction (“A” is to “B”). Since some have allergies to peanuts, no one should be served peanuts (“C” is to “D”). Another, more controversial example that is used almost daily: a person used a gun to murder someone. Since someone used a gun to murder someone, no one should be able to own a gun.
As for Partridge’s book, perhaps the most egregious example is his mentioning a guest appearance by a Rabbi at a church. During the discussion, the question comes up: Did the Jews kill Jesus? The minister, seeking to be polite says that we all did, Jews and Gentiles alike. Partridge does not quote the Rabbi directly, but states that in essence he said in so many words…. Partridge then references a Wikipedia article that states that the Talmud, Gitten 57a, says that Jesus was demon possessed, is facing God’s wrath, and is boiling in excrement. Thus the Rabbi’s statement, thus the Talmud, and by inference, thus all Jews.
Let us take a detailed look at Gitten 57a. What does it say? The passage deals with a necromancer, Onkelos, who calls up both Balaam and Jesus, asking each of them what their punishment in the afterlife is. It is true that Gitten 57a does speak of Jesus suffering the punishment of being in boiling excrement (the meaning of then named character, “Yashu,” is sometimes debated, and not all texts include it). What is curious is that the text goes on to state that Yashu sought the good of the people whereas Balaam desired their harm. The key point for our purposes is that the text declares that both spirits were brought up through the use of necromancy by Onkelos.
Consider Deuteronomy 18:10–11 (ESV): “There shall not be found among you anyone who burns his son or his daughter as an offering, anyone who practices divination or tells fortunes or interprets omens, or a sorcerer or a charmer or a medium or a necromancer or one who inquires of the dead, for whoever does these things is an abomination to the LORD. And because of these abominations the LORD your God is driving them out before you.”
Doesn’t the Torah itself invalidate what the Talmud speaks of in this case? Given how the passage forbids the use of necromancy as found in Gitten 57a, what does that say about Onkelos? it is not wise to ground one’s conclusions based on that Talmudic passage. Does using demonic methods to get an answer ever result in anything good? No. Are demons known for being truthful? No. Jesus stated that Satan was the father of lies.
Nevertheless, Partridge uses this argument for his theological position against the Jews and against Israel. It is noteworthy that antisemites tend to favor the Talmud over the Torah, the non-canonical and sometimes, as here, its anti-biblical writings over the Hebrew canon. The Talmud includes all sorts of things that the Torah does not. As we have just noted, the Old Testament makes it clear that those who engage in occultic practices such as necromancy are eternally lost.
And that leads us to Partridge’s replacement theology, which we will examine in the next post.
Posted in Book Reviews
Recent
A Cautionary Tale: Annette Capps
November 6th, 2026
The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 5
November 4th, 2026
The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 4
November 2nd, 2026
The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 3
October 30th, 2026
The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 2
October 28th, 2026
Archive
2026
January
April
May
Whom Do We Listen To? Part 10Whom Do We Listen To? Part 11Whom Do We Listen To? Part 12Whom Do We Listen To? Part 13Whom Do We Listen To? Part 14Whom Do We Listen To? Part 15Whom Do We Listen To? Part 16Whom Do We Listen To? Part 17Whom Do We Listen To? Part 18Whom Do We Listen To? Part 19Whom Do We Listen To? Part 20Whom Do We Listen To? Part 21
June
August
John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 1John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 2John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 3John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 4John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 5John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 6John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 7John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 8Revisiting the NAR, Part 1Revisiting the NAR, Part 2Revisiting the NAR, Part 3The NAR: Teaching about a Spirit of Religion, Part 1
September
The NAR: Teaching about a Spirit of Religion, Part 2The NAR: Teaching about a Spirit of Religion, Part 3The NAR: Teaching about a Spirit of Religion, Part 4The NAR: C. Peter Wagner's Core Teachings, Part 1The NAR: C. Peter Wagner's Core Teachings, Part 2The NAR: C. Peter Wagner's Core Teachings, Part 3
October
The NAR: Historic Sources of Their Core TeachingsThe NAR: E.W. Kenyon: A Key Predecessor, Part 1The NAR: E.W. Kenyon: A Key Predecessor, Part 2The NAR: E.W. Kenyon: A Key Predecessor, Part 3The NAR: E.W. Kenyon: A Key Predecessor, Part 4The NAR: E.W. Kenyon: A Key Predecessor, Part 5The NAR: E.W. Kenyon: A Key Predecessor, Part 6The NAR: Kenneth Hagin: An Indirect Forerunner, Part 1The NAR: Kenneth Hagin: An Indirect Forerunner, Part 2The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 1The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 2The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 3
2025
March
September
Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 1Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 2Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 3Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 4Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 5Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 6

No Comments