John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 2

Thought for Today, August 7, 2026
John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 2
Is Comer’s book, “Practicing the Way,” worth reading? On one level the answer appears to be, “Yes,” but on a deeper level, the book has major flaws.
As mentioned, the book is deeply rooted in Postmodernism. One of the key postmodernists, Richard Rorty, was honest enough to explain how they use language. The same words are used, but are redefined, intending that by the time others have realized what was done, they’ve been converted to the Postmodern position. What we find therefore is a fundamental level of dishonesty, to disguise what is meant by making it to appear to mean something else.
Comer’s book, on one level, is about the need to practice spiritual disciplines. That is a valid, beneficial point. The trouble is that on a deeper level, Comer appears to have a very different agenda.
The biggest problem: Scripture. We looked briefly at his practices list in the previous post. Did you notice? Scripture was listed only as #5. Instead of filtering everything through the grid of Scripture, other, often subjective, ways of hearing from God have priority. The danger of being deceived is magnified. Does God speak to us through prayer? Absolutely! But we still must take the step of confirming what we think God has said to us through prayer and make sure that what we heard aligns with Scripture. If it doesn’t, guess what? God didn’t speak it. And, if we’re being honest, our hearing of God isn’t perfect. We need that scriptural grid.
We will look at some of the scriptural problems within the book in detail. Some of the misuses are quite subtle. Regarding one of the author’s points:
Page xvi: “Contrary to what many assume, Jesus did not invite people to convert to Christianity. He didn’t even call people to become Christians (keep reading…); he invited people to apprentice under him into a whole new way of living. To be transformed.”
Page 14: “Just to make it crystal clear… Christian 3x Apprentice 269x”
On one level, is what Comer states, biblically accurate (laying aside his use of “apprentice” for the moment)? Yes. But, is it biblically true? No. Is he writing to mislead? Yes. When was the church formed? Was it formed during Jesus’s life, or birthed at the time of the arrival of the Holy Spirit in Acts 2? The church was born in Acts 2. The point is that the term “Christian,” and the creation of the church, wasn’t the focus during Jesus’s ministry. He would only rarely refer to something that didn’t yet exist.
What about Comer’s use of “apprentice”? He almost never uses the word “disciple,” redefining apprentice to make it appear as something like disciple.
For example, page 120: “‘Go and make apprentices of all kinds of people.’ So read Jesus’ closing words to his apprentices.’”
Here is Comer’s four step apprentice program, page 121: “1. I do; you watch. 2. I do; you help. 3. You do; I help. 4. You do; I watch.”
We do see something like that in Jesus’s training of the twelve disciples, don’t we? But is that where it starts? No. We first must be changed. Among the twelve, one was not changed: Judas Isacariot. He went through the “apprentice” program. Is he the model apprentice? Obviously, no. We can follow Comer’s four steps, and not be inwardly changed.
Admittedly, per postmodern thought the order is reversed. One does, then one becomes, as opposed to the older understanding one becomes, then one does. Thus, according to postmdernism, arguably one first lives like a Christian and then one becomes a Christian. But is that how it works biblically? No. Doesn’t that sound all-too-close to a “gospel of works”? Yes.
Comer rewrites Scripture to make it better suit his purposes. It may have a “fresh edgy” feel to it, but it isn’t what Scripture states. “Disciple” has a permanence to it that “apprentice” doesn’t. After an apprentice has finished their training, the apprentice goes off on their own, separate from the master.
That isn’t the only time he redefines classic understanding of the Scriptures. We will continue to give examples of Comer’s twisting of Scripture in the next post.

Posted in

No Comments


Recent

Archive

 2026

Categories

Tags

no tags