Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 3

Thought for Today, September 10, 2025
Dale Partridge: “The Israel Delusion”: Book Review, Part 3
What do we make of Dale Partridge’s book: “The Israel Delusion”? As we will see, he insists that the church replaces Israel. The Jews have no future.
In the previous post, we saw that Partridge starts by basing his view on a Rabbi’s comments about Jesus. What does he go on to say about the Jews, and about Israel?
Partridge references numerous verses from the Gospel of John and Jesus’s debates with the Jews. Perhaps chief among them is John 8:44, where Jesus declares that the Jews he was debating had the devil as their father. Given his methodology, his implication is clear: Jews are devils. Partridge eventually goes on to state, “Jesus is the true Israel” (page 34). How? Jesus is the better Moses: Jesus leads out of sin, Moses only lead Israel out of Egypt (page 30). The Israelites wandered in the desert for forty years in the desert and failed. Jesus fasted in the wilderness for forty days and overcame Satan (page 31); Jacob had twelve sons that started the twelve tribes, Jesus had twelve disciples. Several similar examples could be cited.
On one level, the comparisons make sense, but on the other hand, how does the disciple Judas correspond to one of the twelve tribes? Also, in the New Jerusalem, the twelve disciples do not replace the twelve tribes: the twelve foundations are named after the twelve apostles while the twelve gates are named after the twelve tribes. So at that point, the analogy completely breaks down.
The Jews have no future. Partridge mentions the Crusades, and how the crusaders understood that they were liberating the Promised Land and Jerusalem for the Church, not for the Jews (page 46). He omits the fact that the Crusaders sometimes slaughtered the Jews. In addition, Partridge references Romans 9:6–8, along with a few other passages to denote that not all Israel is Israel, specifically that the Jews are not the true Israel; the church is (pages 24–25). They violated their conditional covenant and therefore have been rejected. Besides, Israel, as it exists today, is a secular, sinful nation, nothing more. Their land belongs to the Church. Partridge takes pains to insist that he is not being antisemitic.
Partridge summarizes: “Can the millions of Christ-rejecting Jews—those who have lived and died apart from Christ and now burning in hell really be called ‘God’s chosen people’? Scripture answers with a resounding: No” (page 49).
The biblical omissions in Partridge’s arguments are massive. Nowhere does he discuss the numerous Old Testament promises regarding Israel’s eventual salvation. His only reference to Romans 9–11 is to use it to state that not all Israel is Israel, inferring that all Jews are apostate, replaced by the church. But that isn’t what God says in those chapters. Romans 11:11 is clear: Israel’s rejection of the Gospel brought about salvation for the Gentiles. Romans 11:26–27 indicates that all Israel, meaning Israel, not the church, at some future point will be saved. Verse 28 tells us that Israel is still beloved by God, while verse 29 indicates that God’s calling, here related to Abraham, is irrevocable.
A. Blake White, while taking a similar view, addresses Romans 11 and other passages that Partridge omits. In his book “God’s Chosen People,” he states that “all Israel” means “all elect Jews who will come to Christ throughout history” (page 129). Like Partridge, White finds no place for the nation of Israel. For him, Romans 11 is a present-tense reality; it contains no element of things future. Kim Riddlebarger, in his book, “A Case for Amillennialism,” citing Calvin, takes another step, stating that Israel was really the church in its infancy (page 132). Thus Israel, from its very beginning, is folded into the church. Disagreeing with White, he states that ethnic Israel will be saved, but that this will take place close to the end-time resurrection, not to any sort of millennial kingdom (page 221).
It is difficult to see how one can interpret “all” to mean something less than “all,” or that Israel isn’t Israel, but the earliest church. Yet doing so is necessary in order to maintain the position where the Church replaces Israel. Admittedly, every theological system has strengths and weaknesses. Whether it is covenant theology, dispensationalism, free-will Baptist, Calvinist, or whatever. As Christians, we are finite individuals trying to grasp hold of the infinite God. None of us have it fully figured out. The wisest thing to do is to keep Scripture primary and theological systems secondary.
Nevertheless, Partridge’s replacement theology fails to address key Scriptures. Can one string together verses to seemingly justify it? Yes. But the position ignores many biblical passages that speak directly against it. Those passages must either be skipped, finessed to mean something else, or interpreted symbolically.
Yet there is even a deeper problem with Partridge’s replacement theology, a problem that has been growing rapidly for the past several decades. We will turn to that issue in the next post.

Posted in

No Comments


Recent

Archive

 2026

Categories

Tags

no tags