John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 5
Thought for Today, August 14, 2026
John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 5
We’ve seen how Comer misuses and twists Scripture. Comer also has a disdain for the Western Church, especially classical evangelicalism.
Comer states, page 5, “To a large number of Western Christians, he is a delivery mechanism for a particular theory of atonement, as if the only reason he came was to die, not to live.”
He adds, page 19, “This is the ‘gospel’ as it is presented in many circles… You are a sinner going to hell. God loves you. Jesus died on the cross for your sins. If you believe in him, you can go to heaven when you die. Now, much could be said about this ‘gospel’—namely, that it doesn’t sound anything at all like the gospel Jesus himself preached…. It simply does not come close to the full picture of salvation we find in Jesus’ preaching or the writings of the New Testament.”
We’ve seen in a previous post how Comer takes what Jesus says out of context to make it appear to mean something else, especially as it relates to Christianity. Beyond that, do churches claim that what is intended as an “invitation” represent the entirety of Christian life? No. The need to become disciples is stressed.
Yet, note what God said was essential, through Paul, in 1 Corinthians 15:3–5 (NAU): “For I delivered to you as of first importance what I also received, that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures, and that He was buried, and that He was raised on the third day according to the Scriptures, and that He appeared to Cephas, then to the twelve.”
What did Jesus promise His disciples just before His crucifixion: He was going away to prepare a place for them and would come back for them. Although not phrased well, the “go to heaven” means to be with God for all eternity.
So, in essence, we see Comer coming dangerously close to ridiculing what God states is most important, and what Jesus promised. In some ways, 2 Peter 3:3–4 comes to mind; God’s warning about those who will scoff about Christ’s return.
Comer makes several comments along the following line (page 87): “My point is that church attendance, good sermons, and regular Bible study are all good—more than good, essential. But we must be honest: by themselves, they have a very poor track record of yielding a high level of transformation in large numbers of people.”
Here is one more, page 175: “I know some people who never miss a week of church, read through the entire Bible every year, and never watch R-rated movies (all good things) but who are still self-righteous, controlling, fueled by anger, blind to their own shadow, and, at times, incredibly unloving.”
We can all cite an example of a person in church or denomination “X” who isn’t really following Christ. Sadly, they exist in every church—not everyone who claims to be a Christian actually is one. But why does Comer choose to cite this specific example, within this specific type of church?
For Comer, in and of themselves, church services, sermons, and especially disciplined regular Bible reading don’t help with spiritual formation for “large numbers of people.” In other words, what the Reformation has emphasized, particularly “sola scriptura” hasn’t worked, and therefore must not be the answer.
Where then, do we turn to learn about “real” spiritual formation, if Scripture and church aren’t effective? We’ll look at that question in the next post.
John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 5
We’ve seen how Comer misuses and twists Scripture. Comer also has a disdain for the Western Church, especially classical evangelicalism.
Comer states, page 5, “To a large number of Western Christians, he is a delivery mechanism for a particular theory of atonement, as if the only reason he came was to die, not to live.”
He adds, page 19, “This is the ‘gospel’ as it is presented in many circles… You are a sinner going to hell. God loves you. Jesus died on the cross for your sins. If you believe in him, you can go to heaven when you die. Now, much could be said about this ‘gospel’—namely, that it doesn’t sound anything at all like the gospel Jesus himself preached…. It simply does not come close to the full picture of salvation we find in Jesus’ preaching or the writings of the New Testament.”
We’ve seen in a previous post how Comer takes what Jesus says out of context to make it appear to mean something else, especially as it relates to Christianity. Beyond that, do churches claim that what is intended as an “invitation” represent the entirety of Christian life? No. The need to become disciples is stressed.
Yet, note what God said was essential, through Paul, in 1 Corinthians 15:3–5 (NAU): “For I delivered to you as of first importance what I also received, that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures, and that He was buried, and that He was raised on the third day according to the Scriptures, and that He appeared to Cephas, then to the twelve.”
What did Jesus promise His disciples just before His crucifixion: He was going away to prepare a place for them and would come back for them. Although not phrased well, the “go to heaven” means to be with God for all eternity.
So, in essence, we see Comer coming dangerously close to ridiculing what God states is most important, and what Jesus promised. In some ways, 2 Peter 3:3–4 comes to mind; God’s warning about those who will scoff about Christ’s return.
Comer makes several comments along the following line (page 87): “My point is that church attendance, good sermons, and regular Bible study are all good—more than good, essential. But we must be honest: by themselves, they have a very poor track record of yielding a high level of transformation in large numbers of people.”
Here is one more, page 175: “I know some people who never miss a week of church, read through the entire Bible every year, and never watch R-rated movies (all good things) but who are still self-righteous, controlling, fueled by anger, blind to their own shadow, and, at times, incredibly unloving.”
We can all cite an example of a person in church or denomination “X” who isn’t really following Christ. Sadly, they exist in every church—not everyone who claims to be a Christian actually is one. But why does Comer choose to cite this specific example, within this specific type of church?
For Comer, in and of themselves, church services, sermons, and especially disciplined regular Bible reading don’t help with spiritual formation for “large numbers of people.” In other words, what the Reformation has emphasized, particularly “sola scriptura” hasn’t worked, and therefore must not be the answer.
Where then, do we turn to learn about “real” spiritual formation, if Scripture and church aren’t effective? We’ll look at that question in the next post.
Posted in Book Reviews
Recent
A Cautionary Tale: Annette Capps
November 6th, 2026
The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 5
November 4th, 2026
The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 4
November 2nd, 2026
The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 3
October 30th, 2026
The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 2
October 28th, 2026
Archive
2026
January
April
May
Whom Do We Listen To? Part 10Whom Do We Listen To? Part 11Whom Do We Listen To? Part 12Whom Do We Listen To? Part 13Whom Do We Listen To? Part 14Whom Do We Listen To? Part 15Whom Do We Listen To? Part 16Whom Do We Listen To? Part 17Whom Do We Listen To? Part 18Whom Do We Listen To? Part 19Whom Do We Listen To? Part 20Whom Do We Listen To? Part 21
June
August
John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 1John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 2John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 3John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 4John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 5John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 6John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 7John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 8Revisiting the NAR, Part 1Revisiting the NAR, Part 2Revisiting the NAR, Part 3The NAR: Teaching about a Spirit of Religion, Part 1
September
The NAR: Teaching about a Spirit of Religion, Part 2The NAR: Teaching about a Spirit of Religion, Part 3The NAR: Teaching about a Spirit of Religion, Part 4The NAR: C. Peter Wagner's Core Teachings, Part 1The NAR: C. Peter Wagner's Core Teachings, Part 2The NAR: C. Peter Wagner's Core Teachings, Part 3
October
The NAR: Historic Sources of Their Core TeachingsThe NAR: E.W. Kenyon: A Key Predecessor, Part 1The NAR: E.W. Kenyon: A Key Predecessor, Part 2The NAR: E.W. Kenyon: A Key Predecessor, Part 3The NAR: E.W. Kenyon: A Key Predecessor, Part 4The NAR: E.W. Kenyon: A Key Predecessor, Part 5The NAR: E.W. Kenyon: A Key Predecessor, Part 6The NAR: Kenneth Hagin: An Indirect Forerunner, Part 1The NAR: Kenneth Hagin: An Indirect Forerunner, Part 2The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 1The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 2The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 3
2025
March
September
Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 1Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 2Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 3Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 4Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 5Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 6

No Comments