John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 8
Thought for Today, August 21, 2026
John Mark Comer” Practicing the Way? Part 8
Comer’s combining Roman Catholic and Greek Orthodox theological and mystical thought leads him to some dangerous beliefs. We’ve already seen his disdain for forms of Western Christianity that are based first and foremost on Scripture (and even aspects of Roman Catholicism). We’ve seen him remark how serious Scripture reading hasn’t had a great track record regarding spiritual formation. It is therefore not surprising that he embraces a paradigm that often reflects Eastern Orthodoxy and “Christian” mysticism.
He states, page 23: “Jesus didn’t go around beating up on self-effort. As the saying goes, ‘Grace is not opposed to effort, it is opposed to earning.’ Don’t conflate the two.” The quote is from Dallas Willard. What we see is that self-effort is somehow involved in the process of our salvation. His attempt at clarifying through “earning” is not convincing.
Comer adds, page 76: “Formation isn’t a Christianized version of project self; it’s a process of salvation. Of being saved by Jesus.” Once again, we see that while we are saved by Jesus, it is a process of salvation at least in part through our formative efforts. Is Comer possibly confusing or conflating “salvation” with “sanctification”? It doesn’t appear so, since he rejects what he called “the forensic view” (an oversimplification by Comer). Still, it isn’t totally clear.
Note how Comer views sin, page 93: “To that end, one paradigm that I find especially helpful for spiritual formation purposes is the idea of sin as a kind of disease of the soul and salvation as the healing of the whole person. As the Christian psychologist and expert on trauma Dan Allender put it, ‘We seldom see sin, at first sight, as what it truly is—ill and deforming.’”
Is sin just a “disease of the soul”? Is sin just deforming? One can certainly make a strong biblical case that sin deforms. But is that it? What is missing is the stark reality that, prior to salvation through Christ, sin was my core identity. I was a sinner. As Ephesians 2 puts it, I was dead in my trespasses and sin. The good news is that through Christ, through Christ’s death on the cross, through His taking my place, I am a new creature in Christ. He took on my sin, I took on His righteousness (2 Corinthians 5:17–21). Talk about a great thing to contemplate!
Comer embraces silence, but to a far greater degree than Scripture commands (see Habakkuk 2:20), page 183, quoting the mystic Isaac the Syrian, “‘Speech is the organ of the present world. Silence is the mystery of the world to come.’ In silence we enter the mystery of the world to come—and into God himself.”
Does the book of Revelation describe the world to come as a world of silence? Not hardly! Rather, doesn’t the “mystery… into God himself,” sound more like Eastern mysticism, a New Age ideal?
We also see Comer adopting a dangerously universalist somewhat Eastern Orthodox view, page 149: “He is near me in everything that I see and touch, in everyone whom I encounter.” He, meaning God, is “in everyone whom I encounter.” That is not unlike a type of panentheism. Once again, we’re talking Eastern mysticism/New Age beliefs, not biblical Christianity.
Many more examples could be given. For Comer, any activity, include exercise and walking one’s dog could be a spiritual practice or discipline. Whatever works for a person is fine. He even paints Saint Benedict and his Rule in a similar flexible light. Benedict’s rule states something quite different. Page 51 of the edition I have states that a monk is allowed no individual rights or desires. The monk must not even question the abbot about any of his decisions. So much for Comer’s portrait.
It is easy to understand why Comer’s book is so popular. You can set your own spiritual practices. It is best to base them on historical practices, but that isn’t essential. Does one have to become a Christian to follow Jesus? Maybe, probably.
Is the book worth placing on one’s reading list? No. Although it does make some good points about spiritual formation, it contains so much outright biblical error, so many questionable assertions, and so many omissions, that overall, it isn’t biblically helpful, and there is a real possibility that the book will draw people away from core Biblical truth.
Rather than going to Christian mystics for our practices and beliefs, aren’t we far better off looking to Scripture? Of course mystics will tickle our ears in ways that Scripture does not. After all, God uses Scripture to convict us of our sin. Mystics, even “Christian” mystics, often tell us what we want to hear. So does Comer. But Scripture is our safeguard, our best source for knowing God, our best defense from swallowing error, the best thing for us to contemplate.
John Mark Comer” Practicing the Way? Part 8
Comer’s combining Roman Catholic and Greek Orthodox theological and mystical thought leads him to some dangerous beliefs. We’ve already seen his disdain for forms of Western Christianity that are based first and foremost on Scripture (and even aspects of Roman Catholicism). We’ve seen him remark how serious Scripture reading hasn’t had a great track record regarding spiritual formation. It is therefore not surprising that he embraces a paradigm that often reflects Eastern Orthodoxy and “Christian” mysticism.
He states, page 23: “Jesus didn’t go around beating up on self-effort. As the saying goes, ‘Grace is not opposed to effort, it is opposed to earning.’ Don’t conflate the two.” The quote is from Dallas Willard. What we see is that self-effort is somehow involved in the process of our salvation. His attempt at clarifying through “earning” is not convincing.
Comer adds, page 76: “Formation isn’t a Christianized version of project self; it’s a process of salvation. Of being saved by Jesus.” Once again, we see that while we are saved by Jesus, it is a process of salvation at least in part through our formative efforts. Is Comer possibly confusing or conflating “salvation” with “sanctification”? It doesn’t appear so, since he rejects what he called “the forensic view” (an oversimplification by Comer). Still, it isn’t totally clear.
Note how Comer views sin, page 93: “To that end, one paradigm that I find especially helpful for spiritual formation purposes is the idea of sin as a kind of disease of the soul and salvation as the healing of the whole person. As the Christian psychologist and expert on trauma Dan Allender put it, ‘We seldom see sin, at first sight, as what it truly is—ill and deforming.’”
Is sin just a “disease of the soul”? Is sin just deforming? One can certainly make a strong biblical case that sin deforms. But is that it? What is missing is the stark reality that, prior to salvation through Christ, sin was my core identity. I was a sinner. As Ephesians 2 puts it, I was dead in my trespasses and sin. The good news is that through Christ, through Christ’s death on the cross, through His taking my place, I am a new creature in Christ. He took on my sin, I took on His righteousness (2 Corinthians 5:17–21). Talk about a great thing to contemplate!
Comer embraces silence, but to a far greater degree than Scripture commands (see Habakkuk 2:20), page 183, quoting the mystic Isaac the Syrian, “‘Speech is the organ of the present world. Silence is the mystery of the world to come.’ In silence we enter the mystery of the world to come—and into God himself.”
Does the book of Revelation describe the world to come as a world of silence? Not hardly! Rather, doesn’t the “mystery… into God himself,” sound more like Eastern mysticism, a New Age ideal?
We also see Comer adopting a dangerously universalist somewhat Eastern Orthodox view, page 149: “He is near me in everything that I see and touch, in everyone whom I encounter.” He, meaning God, is “in everyone whom I encounter.” That is not unlike a type of panentheism. Once again, we’re talking Eastern mysticism/New Age beliefs, not biblical Christianity.
Many more examples could be given. For Comer, any activity, include exercise and walking one’s dog could be a spiritual practice or discipline. Whatever works for a person is fine. He even paints Saint Benedict and his Rule in a similar flexible light. Benedict’s rule states something quite different. Page 51 of the edition I have states that a monk is allowed no individual rights or desires. The monk must not even question the abbot about any of his decisions. So much for Comer’s portrait.
It is easy to understand why Comer’s book is so popular. You can set your own spiritual practices. It is best to base them on historical practices, but that isn’t essential. Does one have to become a Christian to follow Jesus? Maybe, probably.
Is the book worth placing on one’s reading list? No. Although it does make some good points about spiritual formation, it contains so much outright biblical error, so many questionable assertions, and so many omissions, that overall, it isn’t biblically helpful, and there is a real possibility that the book will draw people away from core Biblical truth.
Rather than going to Christian mystics for our practices and beliefs, aren’t we far better off looking to Scripture? Of course mystics will tickle our ears in ways that Scripture does not. After all, God uses Scripture to convict us of our sin. Mystics, even “Christian” mystics, often tell us what we want to hear. So does Comer. But Scripture is our safeguard, our best source for knowing God, our best defense from swallowing error, the best thing for us to contemplate.
Posted in Book Reviews
Recent
A Cautionary Tale: Annette Capps
November 6th, 2026
The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 5
November 4th, 2026
The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 4
November 2nd, 2026
The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 3
October 30th, 2026
The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 2
October 28th, 2026
Archive
2026
January
April
May
Whom Do We Listen To? Part 10Whom Do We Listen To? Part 11Whom Do We Listen To? Part 12Whom Do We Listen To? Part 13Whom Do We Listen To? Part 14Whom Do We Listen To? Part 15Whom Do We Listen To? Part 16Whom Do We Listen To? Part 17Whom Do We Listen To? Part 18Whom Do We Listen To? Part 19Whom Do We Listen To? Part 20Whom Do We Listen To? Part 21
June
August
John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 1John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 2John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 3John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 4John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 5John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 6John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 7John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 8Revisiting the NAR, Part 1Revisiting the NAR, Part 2Revisiting the NAR, Part 3The NAR: Teaching about a Spirit of Religion, Part 1
September
The NAR: Teaching about a Spirit of Religion, Part 2The NAR: Teaching about a Spirit of Religion, Part 3The NAR: Teaching about a Spirit of Religion, Part 4The NAR: C. Peter Wagner's Core Teachings, Part 1The NAR: C. Peter Wagner's Core Teachings, Part 2The NAR: C. Peter Wagner's Core Teachings, Part 3
October
The NAR: Historic Sources of Their Core TeachingsThe NAR: E.W. Kenyon: A Key Predecessor, Part 1The NAR: E.W. Kenyon: A Key Predecessor, Part 2The NAR: E.W. Kenyon: A Key Predecessor, Part 3The NAR: E.W. Kenyon: A Key Predecessor, Part 4The NAR: E.W. Kenyon: A Key Predecessor, Part 5The NAR: E.W. Kenyon: A Key Predecessor, Part 6The NAR: Kenneth Hagin: An Indirect Forerunner, Part 1The NAR: Kenneth Hagin: An Indirect Forerunner, Part 2The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 1The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 2The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 3
2025
March
September
Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 1Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 2Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 3Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 4Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 5Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 6

No Comments