Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 4

Thought for Today, September 12, 2025
Dale Partridge: “The Israel Delusion”: Book Review, Part 4
According to Dale Partridge’s “The Israel Delusion,” the Jews have no place. They have been permanently rejected. They violated their conditional covenant with God and therefore they are done. The Promised Land now belongs to the Church. The Church has replaced Israel and has inherited Israel’s biblical promises. The nation of Israel is bogus, nothing more than an ungodly secular state. Thus does Partridge posit at length.
But in the last several decades, he is not the only Christian to proclaim the illegitimacy of the Jews and the state of Israel. It is certainly true that at present, Israel is a secular state. But as we saw, Romans 9–11, coupled with numerous Old Testament promises, indicates that at a future point, God will change their situation.
But, what other Christians are proclaiming similar messages to Partridge? The answer: Arab Christians; Arab Christians living under the Islamic thumb, along with European clergy; those who have chosen to align themselves with Islam, against Israel and the Jews.
Why? Christians living under shariah have no rights except what Islam temporarily cedes to them. In classic Islam, the right to live must be renewed every year, through paying the jizya tax. If a Jew or Christian fails to pay it, their life once again becomes forfeit. They are once again legally subject to becoming a victim of jihad. Beyond that, if they say anything against Islam at all, their life again becomes forfeit. If they express any ingratitude towards Islam, their life becomes forfeit.
The technical term for them is dhimmis: Christian or Jewish unbelievers living under an Islamic state; they are temporarily tolerated under a host of restrictions. They cannot even bring a court case against a Muslim, as under shariah law, their testimony against any Muslim will be refused. In theory, according to some Shiites, non-Muslims may bring cases against Muslims to be heard in Muslim courts. However, as Muslims must be seen as superior in all respects to non-Muslims, historically, actual practice generally has not followed the theory. Sunni jurisprudence, by definition, does not allow non-Muslims to testify against Muslims. Historic and current Islamic authorities are clear: any treaty with dhimmis must benefit the Islamic state and the Muslims.
As we will see in the next post, dhimmis often find themselves in dire circumstances, since they are unable to legally defend themselves. Therefore, it is better to appear to be seen as meek, compliant subjects, than to dare say anything that might further antagonize their Muslim overlords. As the Qur’an spews endless hatred of the Jews, better to try to take the pressure off themselves by agreeing with the Muslims concerning the Jews. Sadly, Partridge’s book falls right into line.

Posted in

No Comments


Recent

Archive

 2026

Categories

Tags

no tags