Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 6

Thought for Today, September 17, 2025
Dale Partridge: “The Israel Delusion”: Book Review, Part 6
In current times, how have the dhimmi Christians responded to their Muslim overlords?
Attempting to take the Islamic heat off themselves, instead of protesting against Islamic discrimination, an act that would threaten their very lives, they join with Muslims in their rejection of and hatred of the Jews. The Christian dhimmis end up functioning as pawns of the Muslims against the Jews. Muslims gladly make use of them. Their spreading, along with European clergy and others, teachings about God’s permanent rejection of, and the illegitimacy of, the Jews, greatly aids the Islamic long-term goals against Israel and is in full agreement with Qur’anic teaching. As Christians, do we really want to side with the demonic teachings of the Qur’an?
As mentioned, does Partridge realize that this is precisely where his belief in replacement theology leads?
The irony is that Muslims lump Jews and Christians together. Both groups are subject to the same restrictions, to the same second-class degraded status. That status even forbids them from teaching their children about Judaism or Christianity. According to Islam, every person is born a Muslim and learns the Jewish or Christian errors through their parents, community, etc. By siding with Muslims, by denying Christianity’s Jewish roots, dhimmi Christians end up destroying their Christianity, ultimately aiding in the spread of Islam.
In addition, the “fact” that everyone is born a Muslim is used to justify the common accepted practice of Muslims kidnapping Christian or Jewish babies and young children, so that those children will receive their proper upbringing in the “true” religion of Islam. That saves them from learning the errors that their Jewish or Christian parents and communities would otherwise teach them (the biblical reality is that all kidnappers/enslavers end up in eternal hell. See Deuteronomy 24:7; 1 Timothy 1:10).
Considering the bigger picture, Islam’s goal is to erase Israel’s history, to delegitimize Israel, to replace Israel with Palestine, and to even turn Jesus into an historical Palestinian (that process is also well underway). Christian replacement theology, as espoused by Partridge and many others, dovetails nicely with those stated Islamic goals.
Thus, we see that replacement theology plays right into the hands of those seeking to ultimately destroy both Israel and the Christian church.
What can we conclude about Partridge’s book? We saw that Partridge’s methodology was highly questionable. He makes use of logical fallacies. He builds up straw-men arguments to fight against. He ignores key Scriptures where God promises that Israel has a future. His replacement theology is in serious biblical error. Due to that error, it also has all sorts of unintended consequences.
Biblically speaking, replacement theology, where the church replaces Israel, is disastrous. It runs counter to the clear teachings of Scripture. However popular Partridge’s book might be, it cannot be recommended.

Posted in

No Comments


Recent

Archive

 2026

Categories

Tags

no tags