The NAR: C. Peter Wagner's Core Teachings, Part 1

Thought for Today, September 9, 2026
The NAR: C. Peter Wagner’s Core Teachings: Part 1
Why are the NAR prophetic decrees so important? Answer: open theism, the belief that God ceded decisions to people, leaving the results open. Therefore, according to this theory, God doesn’t know what will happen.
In the previous series of posts, we cited some of the less-than-biblical teachings of C. Peter Wagner, one of the key founders of the New Apostolic Reformation (NAR). He has written about his delight in discovering open theism in his book, “Dominion! Your Role in Bringing Heaven to Earth (Destiny Image, 2022; a reissue of a book first published in 2008).
Regarding open theism, Wagner states (page 80): “It felt like I was theologically being born again. I finally had a biblical and theological paradigm that made sense of what I had been thinking and what I had been doing all along.”
His decision doesn’t necessarily consider verses in Scripture that would contradict the view. Rather it relates to what he, Wagner, had been doing all along. Note his strong reaction: he places his discovery on the same level as being born again.
Wagner continues (page 81): “Open theism provides another way of thinking about God…. Open theism suggests that, while God decided ahead of time that certain things would happen no matter what, He also decided to leave some other things open and depending on the choices that human beings would make…. In certain situations, God would decide not only to keep things open, but even to choose to prevent Himself from knowing ahead of time what choices we would make.”
He adds (page 82): “Take, for example, Adam and Eve in the garden. Could it be that God chose not to know what decision they would make ahead of time? If so, His Plan A clearly was that they would have dominion, but because of Adam’s bad choice God then decided to go to Plan B. He didn’t create Adam specifically for Plan B, which is where he ended up.”
What are we to make of all of this? First, his denials to the contrary, God is not truly sovereign, humans are. What “we” decide determines eternal outcomes. Second, astoundingly, Jesus was God’s “Plan B.”  I almost wonder if the last “he” in the second quote should be capitalized, since that is also where, according to Wagner, God also ended up. Where in Scripture, is Jesus regarded as a “Plan B”? Nowhere. Beyond that, how does one interpret 1 Peter 1:20 or Ephesians 1:4, to cite two examples that counter Wagner’s claims. It also diminishes Jesus, making Him something of an afterthought.
Then there is 1 John 3:19–20 (NAU): “We will know by this that we are of the truth, and will assure our heart before Him in whatever our heart condemns us; for God is greater than our heart and knows all things.” Thus, Scripture tells us that God does indeed know all things. Once more, Wagner is mistaken.
Nevertheless, based on Wagner’s erroneous interpretation of Scripture, the NAR’s view of decrees makes perfect sense. Since God has ceded decisions to humans, coupled with God’s choice not to know many things, the NAR’s human-issued decrees do determine the course of history, the direction the end-times events will take, events that otherwise may not happen at all.
But it gets worse. In the next post, we will see that Wagner does away with theology, at least theology as historically understood, replacing it with something that has no secure biblical foundation, a decision that opens the door even wider to serious biblical error.

Posted in

No Comments


Recent

Archive

 2026

Categories

Tags

no tags