John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 4

Thought for Today, August 12, 2026
John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 4
Comer’s use of Scripture. We’ve seen him twist it. We’ve seen him misquote it. But he also skips over and omits major biblical themes.
Throughout the book, Comer speaks about Jesus, and His proclamation of the kingdom. But one word of that proclamation is almost entirely absent: repent. While “repent” is central to Jesus’s message, Comer ignores it.
“Repent” only appears twice in Comer’s book. “Repent” appears on page twenty-two, within a verse quoted from Mark, but Comer doesn’t discuss what it means. It shows up a second time on page 220: “When you fall (and again, we all fall), repent, yes, but don’t get sucked into self-recrimination or shame. Fall back on God’s mercy. Let him pick you back up.” Should we avoid self-recrimination? Yes. But, what does “repent” mean? Comer doesn’t say.
There is much more Comer avoids. Does he mention God’s wrath against sin, and towards those who never repent? Not to be found. God’s holiness? Nope.
Comer disdains what is theologically referred to as “penal substitution,” that Jesus had to take our place on the cross. He had to offer Himself, had to suffer for and pay the penalty of our sin, to be our substitute. The biblical word is “propitiation.” We see it in 2 John 4:10 (NAU): “In this is love, not that we loved God, but that He loved us and sent His Son to be the propitiation for our sins.”
Comer describes that view as follows, page 92: “Western Christians (Protestant and Catholic, but especially Protestant) have predominantly thought about sin through the guilt/innocence paradigm—what theologians call a ‘forensic’ (that is, legal) view of sin. The basic idea is that God is a morally serious God; he is not only loving and compassionate but also holy and just. We are guilty before his law of justice, and our only hope is Christ’s pardon. And the good news is that Christ is both ‘just and the justifier.’”
He adds, page 93: “This is a biblical view, but it’s not the biblical view. It’s just the one that’s been emphasized in the West for the last few centuries.”
What the biblical view is, he never says, only offering alternate word pairings, but providing no explanation of any of those paradigms. As we’ve noted, God’s wrath and holiness aren’t on Comer’s radar.
However, he does quote a story Marjorie Thompson told, and references Saint Ignatius of Loyola. Page 46: “I look at Him, He looks at me, and we are happy.” This is the apex of Christian spirituality. Saint Ignatius of Loyola once called God, ‘Love, loving.’”
Comer’s overall view of God, one of only love, isn’t the total picture. Yes, God is love. Absolutely! Is it good to bask in His love? Yes. Comer adds, regarding Saint Ignatius of Loyola (page 46): “In doing so, he spoke for the millions of contemplatives down through history.” Considering history, one must ask: millions? How does Comer arrive at that number of contemplatives?
Rather, as we’ve been saying, God is also holy. Shouldn’t we also reflect on God’s holiness? Of course, that tends to bring us up short, as we become more aware of our sin. But it also leads to gratitude for God’s forgiveness, and for Christ paying the penalty for our sins, of being our substitute (oops, there’s the necessity of that now outdated penal substitution again).
Comer’s view and use of Scripture is quite dangerous. He may have beneficial things to say about spiritual disciplines, but long-term, his view of Scripture could lead to serious trouble. We are finding that the drawbacks of his book far outweigh its benefits.
But there is more. Comer has an utter disdain for the Western Church.

Posted in

No Comments


Recent

Archive

 2026

Categories

Tags

no tags