Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 5

Thought for Today, September 15, 2025
Dale Partridge: “The Israel Delusion”: Book Review, Part 5
Does Partridge realize the consequences of his beliefs? Within the world of Islam, Jews and Christians have no legal standing, other than the right to purchase their miserable lives on a yearly basis; an act of magnanimity on the part of Muslims. After all, Islam teaches that Jews and Christians are destined to the fires of Islamic hell for their refusal to accept Allah and his messenger. As we saw, they have no legal standing in any court case against a Muslim.
Thus, as one might expect, non-Muslims have often been subjected to all sorts of exploitation and extortion, and to all sorts of false accusations by Muslims. These statements include ones that historically often resulted in forced conversions to Islam on pain of death.
If a Muslim claims a Jew (or Christian) has converted to Islam, the Jew has converted, even if he has not. The Muslim’s testimony of the Jew’s conversion stands. Since under shariah, a non-Muslim’s testimony is not accepted against a Muslim, the Jew’s protest that he did not convert is invalid. Worse, the Jew’s claim that he is still a Jew now subjects him to the death penalty, since his claiming to be a Jew means he has committed apostacy and left Islam. The only way he will be spared is if he confirms that he voluntarily converted to Islam. All too often, for obvious reasons, the victim in this type of case affirms his conversion, since the Muslim’s previous testimony about his conversion legally stands as the truth.
The situation is particularly difficult under Sunni law, the predominant form of Islam (about 85% of Muslims are Sunnis). There are cases where the Jew or Christian stayed faithful, accepting their subsequent death rather than deny their faith. Examples of that level of faithfulness are fewer than one would wish for, given the eternal consequences of that type of denial.
As a result of their legal subjugation, Jewish and Christian dhimmis end up living in constant fear, walking on eggshells. They often have resorted to lying and flattery just to survive. Another example under classic shariah: if a Muslim is insulting and physically attacking a Jew or Christian, and the Jew or Christian raises their hand in self-defense, their hand will be cut off. A Jew or Christian must humbly submit to that sort of degradation and must even apologize for their offense of being a Jew or Christian.
In our day, how do Christian dhimmis typically respond to their Muslim overlords? We will turn to that question in the next post, as well as draw some conclusion.

Posted in

No Comments


Recent

Archive

 2026

Categories

Tags

no tags