John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 7
Thought for Today, August 19, 2026
John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 7
Comer wants every Christian to become a mystic, which he redefines as any person who wants to experience transformation. As we noted, personal experience becomes the guide, not Scripture.
Where have past “Christian” mystics ended up? What have they tended to believe? Have they remained true to biblical tenets, or wandered off into syncretism, or even outright heresy?
The problem is the “God” that the mystics tended to find was not necessarily the God described in Scripture. Admittedly, for some, God seemed to be rooted in biblical trinitarian thought, and the Scriptures. For others the “God” found involved blind love and the surrender of one’s thoughts.
The “God” they found was often one of all-consuming “love,” a “love” that either embraced all religions or some form of universal salvation although still found in some way in Christ. Prominent Christian mystics that embraced universalism included Evagrius Ponticus, Isaac the Syrian, Julian of Norwich, Meister Eckhart, and John Scotus Eriugena, among others. Several had visions of ultimate reconciliation.
Many of the mystics saw Jesus as being birthed within them, what was called the mystical incarnation. That mystical incarnation was most important, even more important than salvation through Jesus’s death on the cross. Jesus’s death was seen as having laid the foundation for the mystical incarnation. Is this biblical Christianity? No. The irony, of course, is that through the Holy Spirit, Christ does live within us.
Sometimes various belief systems were combined into a syncretistic whole. One thinks of the famous Roman Catholic mystic Thomas Merton (1915–1968), who ended up merging Buddhism with Christianity. Combining a supposed mystical form of Christianity and a mystical form of Buddhism is far removed from the true Christian faith. It is not encouraging that many have followed him in his inter-faith mystical beliefs.
In many quarters, as with Comer, the mystics are celebrated as having deeper awareness, deeper understanding, deeper communion, a more robust love relationship with the real God. Sadly, the being many have ended up in contact with is far removed from the God of the Scriptures.
Do we really want to follow that path? It is exciting; the path does make wonderful promises, one can find answers beyond Scripture. But does that path lead to the true God, or elsewhere? Isn’t it better to just think on Scripture, to rest in what God has said, including His love for us? The truth of Scripture is certain, the “truths” of our experiences are not. Can our experiences be biblical? Yes. Can our experiences lead us off into serious biblical error? Yes. That is why every experience must be run through the grid of Scripture, rather than running Scripture through the grid of our experiences.
Comer’s looking to Roman Catholic and Greek Orthodox theologians and mystics leads him to some biblically worrisome beliefs. We will look at some of Comer’s beliefs in the next post.
John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 7
Comer wants every Christian to become a mystic, which he redefines as any person who wants to experience transformation. As we noted, personal experience becomes the guide, not Scripture.
Where have past “Christian” mystics ended up? What have they tended to believe? Have they remained true to biblical tenets, or wandered off into syncretism, or even outright heresy?
The problem is the “God” that the mystics tended to find was not necessarily the God described in Scripture. Admittedly, for some, God seemed to be rooted in biblical trinitarian thought, and the Scriptures. For others the “God” found involved blind love and the surrender of one’s thoughts.
The “God” they found was often one of all-consuming “love,” a “love” that either embraced all religions or some form of universal salvation although still found in some way in Christ. Prominent Christian mystics that embraced universalism included Evagrius Ponticus, Isaac the Syrian, Julian of Norwich, Meister Eckhart, and John Scotus Eriugena, among others. Several had visions of ultimate reconciliation.
Many of the mystics saw Jesus as being birthed within them, what was called the mystical incarnation. That mystical incarnation was most important, even more important than salvation through Jesus’s death on the cross. Jesus’s death was seen as having laid the foundation for the mystical incarnation. Is this biblical Christianity? No. The irony, of course, is that through the Holy Spirit, Christ does live within us.
Sometimes various belief systems were combined into a syncretistic whole. One thinks of the famous Roman Catholic mystic Thomas Merton (1915–1968), who ended up merging Buddhism with Christianity. Combining a supposed mystical form of Christianity and a mystical form of Buddhism is far removed from the true Christian faith. It is not encouraging that many have followed him in his inter-faith mystical beliefs.
In many quarters, as with Comer, the mystics are celebrated as having deeper awareness, deeper understanding, deeper communion, a more robust love relationship with the real God. Sadly, the being many have ended up in contact with is far removed from the God of the Scriptures.
Do we really want to follow that path? It is exciting; the path does make wonderful promises, one can find answers beyond Scripture. But does that path lead to the true God, or elsewhere? Isn’t it better to just think on Scripture, to rest in what God has said, including His love for us? The truth of Scripture is certain, the “truths” of our experiences are not. Can our experiences be biblical? Yes. Can our experiences lead us off into serious biblical error? Yes. That is why every experience must be run through the grid of Scripture, rather than running Scripture through the grid of our experiences.
Comer’s looking to Roman Catholic and Greek Orthodox theologians and mystics leads him to some biblically worrisome beliefs. We will look at some of Comer’s beliefs in the next post.
Posted in Book Reviews
Recent
A Cautionary Tale: Annette Capps
November 6th, 2026
The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 5
November 4th, 2026
The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 4
November 2nd, 2026
The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 3
October 30th, 2026
The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 2
October 28th, 2026
Archive
2026
January
April
May
Whom Do We Listen To? Part 10Whom Do We Listen To? Part 11Whom Do We Listen To? Part 12Whom Do We Listen To? Part 13Whom Do We Listen To? Part 14Whom Do We Listen To? Part 15Whom Do We Listen To? Part 16Whom Do We Listen To? Part 17Whom Do We Listen To? Part 18Whom Do We Listen To? Part 19Whom Do We Listen To? Part 20Whom Do We Listen To? Part 21
June
August
John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 1John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 2John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 3John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 4John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 5John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 6John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 7John Mark Comer: Practicing the Way? Part 8Revisiting the NAR, Part 1Revisiting the NAR, Part 2Revisiting the NAR, Part 3The NAR: Teaching about a Spirit of Religion, Part 1
September
The NAR: Teaching about a Spirit of Religion, Part 2The NAR: Teaching about a Spirit of Religion, Part 3The NAR: Teaching about a Spirit of Religion, Part 4The NAR: C. Peter Wagner's Core Teachings, Part 1The NAR: C. Peter Wagner's Core Teachings, Part 2The NAR: C. Peter Wagner's Core Teachings, Part 3
October
The NAR: Historic Sources of Their Core TeachingsThe NAR: E.W. Kenyon: A Key Predecessor, Part 1The NAR: E.W. Kenyon: A Key Predecessor, Part 2The NAR: E.W. Kenyon: A Key Predecessor, Part 3The NAR: E.W. Kenyon: A Key Predecessor, Part 4The NAR: E.W. Kenyon: A Key Predecessor, Part 5The NAR: E.W. Kenyon: A Key Predecessor, Part 6The NAR: Kenneth Hagin: An Indirect Forerunner, Part 1The NAR: Kenneth Hagin: An Indirect Forerunner, Part 2The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 1The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 2The NAR: Charles Capps: The Key Influence, Part 3
2025
March
September
Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 1Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 2Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 3Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 4Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 5Dale Partridge: "The Israel Delusion": Book Review, Part 6

No Comments